Open City by Teju Cole: A Full Review of the Modern African Classic
Image: Faber
Books

Open City by Teju Cole: A Full Review of the Modern African Classic

Arianne ColeArianne Cole··9 min read
Ad SpaceArticle Top - 728x90
Advertisement

Late autumn in Manhattan, in the middle of the 2000s. A psychiatry resident named Julius walks home from his hospital shift through Morningside Heights, down Broadway, into the West Nineties where his apartment is. He walks the next evening too, and the evening after that, because the alternative is the silence of the apartment and the absence of a relationship that has just ended. The walking is the engine and the walking is the form. The novel is the record of where it takes his mind, which is everywhere: to his Lagos boyhood, to a German grandmother he half remembers, to Mahler, to Brussels, to a Liberian detainee in immigration custody, to a Haitian shoeshine, to the birds killed against the city’s lit glass, and finally to a face from his Lagos childhood that he is not prepared to meet again.

Open City, published by Random House in February 2011, was Teju Cole’s first novel. It won the PEN/Hemingway Award for a debut work of fiction in 2012, was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award and was shortlisted for the Ondaatje Prize, and the German translation took the Internationaler Literaturpreis from the Haus der Kulturen der Welt in 2013. The reception in literary New York was immediate. James Wood, reviewing it in The New Yorker, called it a “beautiful, subtle, and, finally, original novel” and placed it in the tradition of W.G. Sebald, whose digressive walking books The Rings of Saturn and Austerlitz had reshaped the possibilities of literary prose in the preceding decade.

The Sebald comparison was the right one and the limiting one. It got the form correct: the wandering narrator, the gentle digressive memory, the long paragraphs that move through history and landscape without scene breaks. It got the freight wrong. Sebald was a German writer working in the shadow of the Holocaust. Cole’s narrator is a Nigerian German psychiatrist in New York, and the histories pressing on him are those of empire, slavery and the dispersal of a continent’s people. The walking is the same. What it carries is not.

What The Walks Carry

Julius is half Nigerian and half German, raised in Lagos, schooled at the Nigerian Military School before his education continued in the United States. He has recently broken up with a girlfriend named Nadege. He visits Professor Saito, an elderly retired teacher of English literature who was his first mentor in America. He has a maternal grandmother he believes may still be alive somewhere in Belgium and has not seen since childhood. He is finishing his psychiatric training and wondering what comes next. None of these facts produces what most novels would call a plot. What the book has instead is the walking, which is also the thinking.

The thinking is what the book is for. Julius passes a building and the building releases a chapter of New York history that he then narrates: the African burial ground uncovered in lower Manhattan in 1991, the Dutch settlement that preceded the city, the ruined smallpox hospital on Roosevelt Island, the prison known as the Tombs. He passes a man and remembers the man’s face from a Lagos schoolyard. He hears Mahler at Carnegie Hall and lets the music braid with a memory of his mother. The novel is structured by these juxtapositions, by the way the walkable surface of Manhattan releases the strata buried under it. Cole is doing what Sebald did in Suffolk and what Walter Benjamin proposed for Paris: reading the city as a palimpsest whose layers are available to anyone willing to walk slowly enough.

The Brussels Detour

About halfway through, Julius travels to Brussels. He is looking for his grandmother and he does not find her. What he finds instead is a city of immigrants and European Muslims, and conversations with strangers that have the slow exploratory texture of a Sebaldian encounter. He meets Farouq, a young Moroccan Belgian intellectual working in a phone and internet shop, who has things to say about Edward Said, about Palestine and about European hospitality, and whom Julius receives politely and at a certain distance. He walks the grey facades of a city he has no childhood in, half remembering a grandmother who may already be dead.

The detour is the structural anomaly of the book. It interrupts the New York walks and transplants Julius to the European capital that administered some of the violence he has been quietly tracking through American history. Brussels is Leopold’s city. Brussels is where decisions about the Congo were taken. Julius does not lecture about this. He walks past it. A reader who knows the history feels the weight without being told, and a reader who does not feels something heavy and ungraspable that the prose keeps brushing against. That is the method throughout: the novel is consistently quieter than its subject matter, and both responses to it are intended.

The Sentences

It is necessary at some point in any review of this book to say what the sentences feel like. Cole’s prose is among the most distinctive in contemporary American fiction. It is patient. It is long. It admits subordinate clauses without anxiety. It moves between observation and reflection without italics or scene break or any of the signalling devices contemporary American fiction has developed for managing transitions. A paragraph can begin at a corner of West End Avenue and end inside a memory of a school dormitory in Lagos without a shift in tone, and the reader follows because the voice has earned the trust required to follow.

Open City
Image: Amazon.com

The voice owes a good deal to Sebald, and something to the essayistic novel more broadly, but it is its own instrument. The Lagos memories carry a specific texture: the heat, the schoolyard violence, Yoruba and English moving through the same sentence, a German mother who never quite became a Lagosian. The New York is observed by someone who is not native to the city and never quite will be, who knows it well enough to walk it for years and remains, at some level, a guest.

Moji, And The Recalibration

Near the end of the book Julius meets a woman named Moji, the older sister of a friend from his Lagos years. She reappears in his New York life, and then, in one quiet and devastating scene, she tells him that he raped her at a party when they were teenagers, and that he has carried on ever since as though it never happened. The reader, who has spent two hundred pages inside a gentle, observant, cultivated consciousness, is recalibrated in a handful of pages. Julius does not dispute her account. He does not confirm it either. He listens, he reflects on himself in a way that does not reach contrition, and the narration moves on.

Ad SpaceIn-Article - 300x250
Advertisement

This is the move that turns Open City from a beautiful Sebaldian wander into something harder. The unreliability has been there the whole time. The reader has been drawn by the quality of the prose into trusting a narrator who is, in at least one decisive respect, not to be trusted. Cole does not punish him in the plot. Julius continues his life. The book runs on for a few more pages and ends with him aboard a boat in New York Harbour after a concert, looking back at the lit city and thinking about the birds that die each year against the Statue of Liberty’s torch.

The Moji scene is what people argue about when they argue about this book. Some readers find it too small a moment to carry the weight it is asked to carry. Others find it the entire point: that a patient, cultivated consciousness can be hosting a violence it has never metabolised, and that the form of the cosmopolitan walker’s novel may be the form best suited to disguising it. The second reading seems to me the stronger one. The novel is doing something with cosmopolitanism that Sebald was not doing, and this is the scene where Cole declares his real subject.

Reception, And The Decade After

Open City arrived at a particular moment in American letters. Ben Lerner’s Leaving the Atocha Station appeared the same year, Sheila Heti’s How Should a Person Be? reached American readers in 2012, and the English translations of Karl Ove Knausgaard began the same year. Cole’s novel was read in that company, as part of a turn toward essayistic, slow paced fiction with an unreliable narrator and a strong autobiographical scent. Cole has resisted the autofiction framing and has been clear that Julius is not him. The book has nonetheless been credited with helping license a generation of essayistic novelists to slow down, digress, walk and refuse plot.

Open City
Image: Penguin Random House

His own career afterwards has been a deliberate undoing of the expectation that a successful first novel sets. He published Every Day Is for the Thief internationally in 2014, a novella that had appeared in Nigeria in 2007. He moved mainly into essays, photography and criticism, with Known and Strange Things in 2016, the photobook Blind Spot in 2017, and Black Paper in 2021. A second novel did not arrive for twelve years. Tremor, published in 2023, returned to the mode with a different protagonist and a more politically explicit weather.

Title Year Form
Every Day Is for the Thief 2007 Nigeria, 2014 US Novella, with photographs
Open City 2011 Novel
Known and Strange Things 2016 Essays
Blind Spot 2017 Photobook with text
Black Paper 2021 Essays and images
Tremor 2023 Novel

Who Should Read It

Read Open City if you want one of the foundational American novels of the century so far, the one that helped redirect a generation toward essayistic, walking, digressive fiction. Read it if you have lived as a foreigner in a city you came to love and want a book that captures that texture of partial belonging. Read it if you are interested in how a Nigerian writer reshaped a German literary inheritance into something neither continental nor American. Read it if you can sit with a short novel whose only plot event of consequence arrives in a handful of pages near the end.

Teju Cole
Image: Teju Cole

Skip it if you need narrative momentum. Skip it if you find the Sebaldian mode distancing. Skip it if you cannot tolerate a narrator whose trustworthiness you are asked to revise without the novel telling you how to feel about the revision.

What This Book Started

Open City did something for the African novel in English that is still being measured. It demonstrated that an African writer in the United States could produce a literary novel that read primarily as American letters, that won American prizes and that taught American writing students how to build a sentence, while carrying a postcolonial freight that never needed to be foregrounded in order to work. After it, younger African and Black British writers had more licence to write into spaces of cosmopolitan ambiguity without being told they were insufficiently African. Cole did not open that door single handed. He widened it.

He also gave a generation of essayists their stride. The slow walker who reads the city, the narrator who refuses to be the protagonist of a plot, the writer who admits the historical layers under the present day surface: that figure is in a great many younger writers now, and the lineage is often traced back through Sebald to Cole.

A Quiet Book With A Long Reach

More than a decade on, Open City reads more strangely than it did at the time, and the strangeness is to its credit. The Sebald comparison matters less now. What is left is the specific texture of Julius’s New York, his Brussels, his Lagos memories, and the way the Moji scene reorganises everything that preceded it. The book is patient. It is unsentimental about its narrator. It is one of a very small number of African novels in English that changed how American literary fiction is written, and the change has outlasted the moment that produced it.

Ad SpaceIn-Article - 300x250
Advertisement
Share
Get the recap

Loved this story? Get more like it.

Join readers who get our weekly entertainment recap - the stories worth your time, delivered every Friday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By signing up you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Open City by Teju Cole: A Full R... | Sidomex Entertainment