Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi: A Full Review of the Modern African Classic
Image: Mahogany Books
Books

Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi: A Full Review of the Modern African Classic

Arianne ColeArianne Cole··10 min read
Ad SpaceArticle Top - 728x90
Advertisement

Cape Coast Castle still stands on the Ghanaian coast, whitewashed and absurdly picturesque against the Gulf of Guinea, and guides walk visitors down into the dungeons where captured Africans were held before the Atlantic crossing. The castle’s upper floors housed British officers, governors and chaplains. The lower floors housed cargo. The doorway through which captives were marched out to the waiting ships is still called the Door of No Return. Yaa Gyasi grew up half a world away in Huntsville, Alabama, the daughter of Ghanaian parents, and she visited the castle as a Stanford undergraduate. The novel that grew out of that visit became one of the most talked about debuts of its decade.

That novel, Homegoing, was published in 2016 by Knopf. It opens in an eighteenth-century Fante village and closes on the Ghanaian coast, at the castle itself. Between those two points it travels more than two centuries, seven generations and fourteen chapters, through a long inventory of historical violence: the Asante and Fante wars, British colonial administration, the Fugitive Slave Act, convict leasing, the Great Migration, the civil rights movement, heroin in Harlem. Each chapter is a self-contained short story. Each chapter is also a link in a chain. The chain holds.

Title Homegoing
Author Yaa Gyasi
First published 2016
Publisher Alfred A. Knopf
Form Novel in fourteen chapters, seven generations, two family lines
Prizes PEN/Hemingway Award; National Book Critics Circle John Leonard Prize; American Book Award; National Book Foundation 5 Under 35 honoree

The Structural Bet

Gyasi’s central formal decision was to organise the novel around two half-sisters who never meet. Their mother, Maame, was enslaved in a Fante compound, bore Effia to the man who owned her, and escaped into Asante territory, where she married and gave birth to Esi. Effia, born in the late eighteenth century, is married off to James Collins, the British governor of Cape Coast Castle, and lives in the upper rooms of the building. Esi is seized in a raid and held in the dungeons below her sister’s bedroom before being shipped to the American South. Neither sister knows the other exists. The novel then alternates chapters between the two bloodlines, one generation at a time, until both threads arrive in the present.

This is a high-risk structure. Most multi-generational novels invest deeply in a small number of characters and trace their relationships across decades. Gyasi gives each descendant a single chapter and then moves on. By the structural logic of the novel, the reader will not see Effia again, and will not see Esi again. Quey, Effia’s son, gets one chapter, and then his son James gets one chapter, and so on down the line. The architecture demands that each character be fully realised in a span shorter than most short stories while also functioning as a relay in a much longer race.

It mostly works. The Ghanaian chapters in particular are dense with sensory texture and historical specificity. The descriptions of palm-wine taverns, missionary schools, the Asante court at Kumasi and the cocoa farms under colonial rule do not feel researched in the bad sense. They feel inhabited. When the architecture wobbles, and it does wobble, the cause is almost always the same: an American chapter with more historical ground to cover than character space to cover it in.

The Ghana Half

Effia’s line stays in West Africa for six generations before the family crosses to the United States. Across those chapters Gyasi tells a history of Ghana that English-language readers rarely get in fictional form. Quey is pressed into the family trade in captives when he would rather have had another life altogether. His son James, born into Asante privilege and in line to inherit a role in that trade, walks away from both to farm and to marry a woman his relatives would never have chosen. James’s daughter Abena waits years on a childhood friend who will not marry her, is left pregnant, and walks to Kumasi, where she gives birth to Akua inside a missionary school and is later killed by the missionary who took her in. Akua, raised in that school and known in her village as Crazy Woman, is haunted by a recurring dream of a woman made of fire, and in one of those episodes she sets her own hut alight and kills her two small daughters. Her son Yaw survives badly scarred and grows up to teach history. Yaw’s daughter Marjorie is born in Ghana and raised in Huntsville, Alabama.

What gives this half its force is Gyasi’s refusal to flatten the Ghanaian side of the Atlantic slave trade into a backdrop. Effia’s husband is a slaver, yes, but Fante and Asante traders also profited from the trade, and Effia’s own mother had been a house slave in her father’s compound. The novel does not lecture, and the moral picture it offers is not a simple one. African kingdoms were not passive victims of European appetite. They were also not equivalent participants. Gyasi sketches a power asymmetry in which Africans operated inside a system whose rules they had not written but whose profits they sometimes shared, a complication that scholars and novelists of the Atlantic world have circled for decades, and she handles it without turning the book into a thesis.

The Akua chapter is for me the strongest in the book. The colonial-era trauma she carries is rendered through dreams and visions that read as folkloric without ever feeling like ornament. Her madness is real madness, the kind that destroys families, but it is also the inheritance of a violence that has no other place to go. Gyasi writes possession and grief in a register that the African literary tradition, Soyinka and Aidoo and Armah among others, has long had room for, and that Anglo-American realist fiction often does not know what to do with.

The America Half

Esi’s bloodline arrives on a slave ship and is funnelled into the cotton economy of the American South. Her daughter Ness is born into slavery. Ness, her husband Sam and their infant son Kojo attempt an escape in which only Kojo gets away: Sam is hanged and Ness is sold on. Kojo grows up a free man in Baltimore until the Fugitive Slave Act makes the city unsafe, and his pregnant wife Anna is seized by slave catchers, so that their son H is born into slavery. H, convicted on a trumped-up charge and sentenced to ten years, ends up in the convict-leasing coal mines of Pratt City, Alabama. H’s daughter Willie joins the Great Migration to Harlem. Willie’s son Sonny becomes an activist who falls into heroin addiction. Sonny’s son Marcus is a Stanford graduate student researching the convict-leasing system that nearly destroyed his great-grandfather.

Homegoing
Image: Adventures in reading, running and working from home

The American chapters carry the heavier historical load. Each one has to do double duty, rendering a character and glossing an entire period. The Pratt City chapter, on H’s life in the post-Reconstruction mines, is the most successful of these, partly because Gyasi has a genuinely under-told subject to work with and partly because the violence of the system itself supplies the chapter’s drive. The Harlem chapter, by contrast, sags. Willie’s marriage to a light-skinned man who passes for white and abandons her is a story we have read before, in Nella Larsen and elsewhere, and Gyasi’s version does not add a great deal to it.

Ad SpaceIn-Article - 300x250
Advertisement

This is the structural weakness that reviewers circled most consistently. The Ghanaian chapters tend to be denser and stranger; the American chapters tend to be tidier and more familiar. Part of this is unavoidable. American chattel slavery and its aftermath have generated an enormous body of fiction in English, and any new entrant is writing into a crowded room. Part of it is a function of Gyasi’s reading life, which by her own account was more saturated in African American literature than in Ghanaian literature when she began the book. The result is that the American chapters often feel like elegant compressions of stories the reader has met before, while the Ghanaian chapters feel like introductions to stories the reader has not.

Politics, Fire, and the Stone

One object runs through both bloodlines. Maame left each of her daughters a black stone pendant veined with gold, which is how the sisters learn, too late to matter, that the other exists. Esi loses hers in the filth of the dungeon floor at Cape Coast Castle before she is shipped out. Effia’s is strung on a necklace and handed down her line until it returns, around Marjorie’s neck, to Ghana, and finally passes into Marcus’s hand. This is the closest Gyasi gets to a unifying symbol, and in a less confident writer the stone would feel like a clumsy meaning-locator. Here it mostly works, partly because she does not overplay it, since the stone disappears for whole chapters, and partly because the novel has earned the gesture by the time the two lines finally cross.

Homegoing
Image: McNally Robinson

That last chapter, in which Marjorie and Marcus meet in California, where he is a graduate student at Stanford, and travel together to Cape Coast, is the book’s most divisive. Some readers find the cousins’ meeting cathartic. Others find it neat. I land closer to the second camp. The novel’s whole structural argument has been that the chain of consequence is so long and so unpredictable that no single reunion can resolve it, and the ending’s gesture toward closure cuts against the harder ethics of everything before it. The reunion is moving on the page. It is also a small betrayal of the form.

Reception and Place in the Canon

Homegoing won the National Book Critics Circle’s John Leonard Prize for a first book, the PEN/Hemingway Award and the American Book Award. It was a New York Times Notable Book, and Gyasi was named a National Book Foundation 5 Under 35 honoree in 2016. Knopf positioned the novel as a debut event, and the publicity cycle that followed was far larger than a first novel usually gets. Reviews in the major British and American papers were broadly admiring, with the most common reservation the one noted above, that the two halves of the book are not of equal strength.

Homegoing
Image: Bookly Club

In the African literary canon the book sits in productive tension with what came before. Ayi Kwei Armah’s The Beautyful Ones Are Not Yet Born and Ama Ata Aidoo’s Our Sister Killjoy did the work of imagining Ghana in fiction for an earlier generation. Gyasi writes as a diaspora author, born in Ghana, raised in Alabama, educated at Stanford and the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, and her novel reflects the dual citizenship of contemporary African letters. She belongs to the same broad cohort as Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, Taiye Selasi, NoViolet Bulawayo and Imbolo Mbue, writers who move between an African childhood or heritage and a Western literary apparatus. Homegoing is one of the defining novels of that wave.

It is also a novel that reshaped what a debut can do. Before Gyasi, the multi-generational sweep was largely the preserve of mid-career writers. Her book demonstrated that a writer in her twenties could attempt one and win prizes for it. Whether that is good for fiction generally is a separate argument. It is certainly true that Homegoing raised the ceiling for what a first book could try and still be taken seriously.

Who Should Read It

Read this if you want a novel that uses formal ambition to make a moral argument about historical entanglement, if you have wanted a literary engagement with Cape Coast Castle that does not flinch from Ghanaian complicity, or if you teach undergraduate courses and need one book that can carry a survey of Atlantic-world history without lecturing. Read it also if you have been told that contemporary African fiction is either village pastoral or postcolonial complaint and you want a counterexample that explodes both categories.

Skip it, or postpone it, if you prefer novels that go deep on a small number of characters across a long book. The serial form here is the point, and readers who want to spend three hundred pages with one consciousness will feel under-served. Skip it also if you are looking for prose that surprises sentence by sentence. Gyasi is a clean stylist, a strong scene-builder and an excellent structural thinker, but she is not, at least in this book, a stylistic original on the level of Helen Oyeyemi or Ben Okri. She is doing other work, and the other work is considerable.

The Room That Holds the Whole Book

What stays with me is not the closing reunion but the second chapter, Esi’s, much of which takes place inside the dungeon at Cape Coast Castle. The waste pit, the heat, the sound of the women around her, the knowledge that James Collins and his new Fante wife are somewhere overhead, eating dinner. That chapter is the moral foundation of the book. Everything else, the seven generations, the stone, the cousins travelling to Ghana, exists because that room existed.

Homegoing was Gyasi’s demonstration that she could write a big book and make it land. She delivered. The cracks in the architecture, the thinner American chapters, the slightly too-tidy ending, are the cracks of a writer reaching for more than her form can quite hold, and reaching was the right move. Her second novel, Transcendent Kingdom, published in 2020, showed that she also knew how to write small. The debut remains the more ambitious of the two, and a generation of writers and readers has been arguing with it, and learning from it, ever since.

Ad SpaceIn-Article - 300x250
Advertisement
Share
Get the recap

Loved this story? Get more like it.

Join readers who get our weekly entertainment recap - the stories worth your time, delivered every Friday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By signing up you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi: A Full R... | Sidomex Entertainment