The Fishermen by Chigozie Obioma: A Full Review of the Modern African Classic
Image: Open Country Mag
Books

The Fishermen by Chigozie Obioma: A Full Review of the Modern African Classic

Arianne ColeArianne Cole··11 min read
Ad SpaceArticle Top - 728x90
Advertisement

Four brothers in Akure walk down to the Omi-Ala river with bamboo rods and a tin of worms. It is 1996. Their father has been transferred by the Central Bank to Yola, more than a thousand kilometres north, and his absence has loosened the discipline that held the household together. The eldest, Ikenna, is fifteen. Boja is fourteen, Obembe eleven, and the narrator, Benjamin, is nine. They have been forbidden to go near the river, which carries a reputation nobody in Akure quite says out loud. They go anyway. They fish for weeks. On one of those afternoons they meet Abulu, a naked, filthy, locally feared madman, who calls out a prophecy that works through the family like a slow toxin until two of the four brothers are dead.

The Fishermen, Chigozie Obioma’s first novel, was published in 2015 by Little, Brown in the United States and by One, an imprint of Pushkin Press, in the United Kingdom. It was shortlisted for the Booker Prize that year, in a field won by Marlon James’s A Brief History of Seven Killings. The shortlisting brought a previously unknown writer from Akure into rooms where Achebe’s name still echoed, and the comparison was immediate: reviewing the novel in the New York Times Book Review, Fiammetta Rocco wrote that Obioma “truly is the heir to Chinua Achebe,” and the New Statesman reached for the same line. It was a heavy garment to drape on a debut.

Title The Fishermen
Author Chigozie Obioma
First published 2015
Publishers One (Pushkin Press), United Kingdom; Little, Brown, United States
Setting Akure, Ondo State, Nigeria, 1996
Prizes Shortlisted for the Booker Prize, 2015

A Family Tragedy In The Abacha Years

The Agwu family is Igbo, living in a largely Yoruba neighbourhood in Akure, Ondo State. The father, Eme, works for the Central Bank of Nigeria and has mapped out his four oldest sons’ futures with the precise hope of a man who lifted himself by clean clerical work: a pilot, a lawyer, a doctor, a professor, in that order of birth. His wife, Adaku, runs a small trade and watches the boys when he is away. There are younger children too, David and Nkem, but the novel’s gravity belongs to the four. It opens with the father’s transfer to Yola, the moment the architecture buckles.

Obioma narrates from Benjamin’s perspective, looking back from adulthood at the nine-year-old he was. The voice is gentle and observational, a brother’s voice, more interested in his siblings than in himself, and the doubleness is one of the book’s craft achievements: the child supplies the mystery and the adult supplies the clarity. Benjamin remembers Ikenna the leader, Boja the second, Obembe the third, himself the fourth, the order they ate in, the way they fought and dressed and slept, the order the prophecy will dismantle.

The book is set during the last brutal years of General Sani Abacha’s regime, and the political weather is everywhere without being announced. The family’s prized possession is a calendar bearing a photograph taken at a campaign rally for Chief M.K.O. Abiola, and Ikenna’s destruction of it is one of the early signs that something in him has turned. Soldiers menace strangers at junctions. The currency convulses. Power cuts last days. Obioma does not lecture about any of this. The Abacha years are simply the air the brothers breathe, in the way Achebe in 1958 let the colonial encounter arrive in Things Fall Apart through small administrative intrusions rather than through pronouncements.

The Prophecy

Abulu is the engine. He is a madman known to the streets of Akure for his nakedness, his filth and his occasional predictions, which have a habit of coming true. When he sees the boys returning from the river he singles Ikenna out by name and foretells a violent death. An aeroplane passes overhead and drowns part of it, so that only Obembe catches the final clause, which he later repeats to his brothers: Ikenna will be killed by a fisherman. Ikenna draws the obvious conclusion, that the fisherman must be one of his own brothers, and hears the words as a sentence already passed. Within weeks he has retreated into himself, suspicious above all of Boja, the brother nearest him in age and the most plausible candidate for the role of executioner.

What Obioma does next is the move that lifts the book from interesting to permanent. He does not write the prophecy as supernatural manipulation. He writes it as psychological infection. Ikenna’s belief poisons his relationship with Boja. Boja, sensing the suspicion, hardens. Their fights escalate. The household watches a fraternal love that had been the spine of the four-boy unit corrode in real time. When the catastrophe comes it is both shocking and inevitable, which is the formal definition of tragedy as Aristotle gave it and as Achebe practised it. Reviewing the novel in the Guardian, Helon Habila made the same point, that for all the prophecies and omens it is character and moral choice that drive the book to its conclusion.

The catastrophe itself is brutally domestic. After weeks of escalating violence the two eldest brothers fight in the backyard, and Benjamin and Obembe run for a neighbour. When they come back the yard is empty and Ikenna is lying stabbed to death in the kitchen. Boja has vanished. A town-wide search ends hours after Ikenna’s funeral, when Boja’s body surfaces in the family well. Because of the taboo on burying a man who has killed his brother and then himself, he is cremated rather than buried. Their mother collapses into a breakdown severe enough to need institutional care. Their father abandons the Yola posting and opens a bookshop in Akure named for the two dead sons.

What Obioma Learned From Achebe

The Achebe comparison was overplayed at the time and is still misunderstood. Obioma is not writing in Achebe’s prose style. His sentences are longer, more lyrical, more given to extended metaphor. What he borrowed is the structural mode. Things Fall Apart is a tragedy of inevitabilities, in which Okonkwo’s flaws and the colonial pressure converge until the rope is the only available exit. The Fishermen runs on the same engine. The catastrophe is loaded in the first chapters. The prophecy is the trigger. Every page after the river is descent.

The other Achebean inheritance is the proverb and the animal. Each chapter carries a single creature as its title, and Benjamin sorts his family into those creatures as he goes, so that Ikenna becomes the python and the chapter earns the name as it proceeds. The frame echoes the Igbo proverb tradition that Achebe described as the palm-oil with which words are eaten. Obioma is announcing his lineage with every chapter heading, and the reader who knows the tradition will recognise what is being claimed.

Where Obioma differs from Achebe is in interiority. Achebe wrote characters whose inner lives we infer from action. Obioma writes brothers whose interior weather we follow minute to minute. This is a twenty-first-century novel as much as it is a child of the 1958 one. The introspective density belongs to Obioma’s generation, the one that read McEwan and Roth alongside Achebe and Soyinka, and it is part of why the book has crossed over to readers who would never have picked up a Heinemann African Writers Series paperback.

The Prose, And What It Risks

Obioma writes in a register that invites the word biblical. Long periodic sentences. Old Testament cadences. Metaphors that swell into multi-clause similes the way water swells a stream after rain. For some readers this is the novel’s incantatory pleasure. For others, especially those raised on Hemingway parsimony, the style can feel mannered. Both responses are honest. The voice is a deliberate non-minimalism, and a reader who needs the kind of sentence Marilynne Robinson writes will be alternately delighted and impatient.

Ad SpaceIn-Article - 300x250
Advertisement
The Fishermen
Image: Hachette Book Group

The other prose risk is the children. Obioma is asking the reader to believe in four brothers who think, in moments, in vocabulary and grammatical structures well beyond their ages. Benjamin, narrating from adulthood, is a partial alibi. Inside the scenes themselves the dialogue and observation sometimes outrun what a nine-year-old, an eleven-year-old or a fifteen-year-old would credibly say. Obioma accepts the risk in service of the larger emotional truth. Whether he gets away with it will depend on each reader’s tolerance for stylisation in a realist frame.

Mama, And What The Book Does With Women

The novel’s emotional centre is not the father, who appears and disappears with the bank’s reassignments, but the mother, who watches the household come apart and whose breakdown in the second half is the book’s most unguarded passage of feeling. Obioma writes her grief without ornament, and her descent into mental illness with a tenderness the rest of the novel’s stylisation sometimes refuses itself. Her scenes are the ones where the prose strips down and the language goes plain, which is its own kind of craft choice and the right one.

Chigozie Obioma
Image: Pa Ikhide

That said, the book is a brother story. The women in it, the mother included, are seen through the brothers’ eyes. A reader who wants African fiction that gives its female characters the same depth of interior weather as its male ones will note the limit. Obioma has been open in interviews about writing out of a specific memory of his own brothers, and the gender of the central tragedy is bound up with that source.

Reception And Aftermath

The Booker shortlist did its work. The novel was translated widely and became a fixture on African literature and postcolonial studies syllabuses in Britain and the United States. It also turned Obioma, who had taken an MFA at the University of Michigan and was beginning a teaching career at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, into a public figure on the Nigerian literary scene, a position he has used to argue for African writers and against the easy commercial flattening of the African novel.

Losing to Marlon James was defensible by most measures, since A Brief History of Seven Killings was the more formally adventurous book, but it placed The Fishermen in a peculiar bracket. It was the great realist tragedy in a year when the prize wanted polyphonic experiment. Obioma’s second novel, An Orchestra of Minorities, published in 2019 and also shortlisted for the Booker, answered that framing directly by handing the narration to an Igbo guardian spirit, a device few realist readers had encountered.

There is also a stage life. A theatre adaptation by Gbolahan Obisesan, built around the two surviving brothers, played the Edinburgh Festival Fringe in 2018 and later ran in London. No film version has been released.

Who This Book Is For

Read The Fishermen if you want a tragedy that earns its catastrophe through patient accumulation, the way the best Greek and Yoruba and Igbo tragedies do. Read it if you have not been to Akure and want to feel the heat of a southwestern Nigerian afternoon as the brothers walk to the river. Read it if you teach the African novel and want a contemporary text that pairs with Things Fall Apart without copying it. Read it if you have brothers, or had them, and want to remember what the gravity of that bond felt like before adulthood loosened it.

The Fishermen
Image: The Santa Barbara Independent

Skip it if you do not have patience for prose that wants to swell. Skip it if the idea of a short novel whose centrepiece is a single act of fraternal violence sounds too narrow to sustain a reading. Skip it if you read fiction primarily for plot velocity, because the velocity here is psychological rather than incident-driven.

Why It Endures

The Fishermen reads better on a second pass than a first. The Booker hype has cooled. The Achebe comparison has been argued through and largely accepted as productive rather than reductive. What remains is the book itself, a tightly engineered family tragedy in which a madman’s words on a riverbank in 1996 ripple through one household with the slow violence of an inherited disease. The book is doing something the African novel has historically done well, which is to dramatise how individual decisions, political weather and ancestral suspicion converge to produce a fate nobody alone is responsible for and nobody can undo.

Obioma has said he wrote the novel partly out of homesickness during his student years abroad, in Cyprus and then the United States, and the homesickness is on every page. Akure is rendered with the specificity of a place a writer has loved and left. The river is rendered with the specificity of a place a writer feared as a child. The brothers are rendered with the specificity of love refined by absence. The novel is a love letter to a southwestern Nigerian boyhood and an indictment of what a single prophecy can do to it.

The Brother Who Lived To Tell It

The last pages do not console. The two younger brothers do not let the prophecy stand: they hunt Abulu, and after a failed attempt with poisoned bread they attack him at the Omi-Ala with weaponised fishing hooks and leave him dead in the water. Obembe flees into exile. Benjamin, who will not abandon his parents, is arrested the next morning and sentenced to be held until he turns eighteen, and he serves roughly six years before an early release. The family he returns to has aged out of recognition and believes Obembe is dead. On the evening of Benjamin’s homecoming a figure climbs over the compound fence, and it is his brother, back on the day he had promised years earlier.

What Obioma gives instead of consolation is the telling. Ikenna and Boja are not coming back. The mother is not coming back to the woman she was. What can be done, the book proposes, is the recording, the witness, the careful naming of who was who and what happened in what order, and how the four boys who walked down to the Omi-Ala that afternoon became three, and then two, and then one in a cell, composing the testimony that opens with the words that give the novel its title. If you are starting Obioma, start here. Read it slowly. Read it twice. Hand it to anyone who has stopped believing the African novel can still do tragedy in the old, hard, undecorated mode.

Ad SpaceIn-Article - 300x250
Advertisement
Share
Get the recap

Loved this story? Get more like it.

Join readers who get our weekly entertainment recap - the stories worth your time, delivered every Friday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By signing up you agree to our Privacy Policy.

The Fishermen by Chigozie Obioma... | Sidomex Entertainment